In this post, we look at how a story works in a place through Janet Burroway’s three principles of effective narrative setting.
If you haven’t read our last article on Burroway, you may be scratching your head right now and thinking, huh? Who’s this Burroway? So, I’ll quickly recap:
Who Is Janet Burroway?
While Burroway may not be a household name among avid readers, she is one among many writers and students of writing craft. With her book, Writing Fiction, Burroway did for contemporary fiction craft what Aristotle did for Classic Greek Drama with his Poetics. She codified and described (not prescribed) what works and what doesn’t in prose fiction.
Ready for some more titbits of craft wisdom from Janet Burroway’s Writing Fiction? Then let’s get right into it!
We are defined by the context in which we live—what, in fictional terms we call our setting. Place, time, climate, values and traditions, all coalesce to form the circumstances necessary to shape us.
If setting’s defining influence is true of real people, it’s doubly true for fictional characters. Just as dialogue must be purposeful and concise, so too must a story’s setting be intentional and relevant.
So, how do we determine what is the best setting for our story? Let’s take a closer look at what setting affords and techniques to take advantage of those opportunities.
Let’s explore Janet Burroway’s three principles of effective narrative setting.
Janet Burroway’s 3 Principles Of Effective Narrative Setting
1. Atmosphere: Place, Time, & Mood
Let’s begin by examining how fictional setting creates atmosphere through three primary components: Place, Time, and Mood.
The writer’s tone is the element that binds and colours all three of these components at once. This is because each component carries with it certain connotations.
- If the story’s place is set in the English countryside, this might create a serene, earthy, and fantastical tone.
- A story set during the Roaring Twenties might add a tone of wild, debauchery-ridden romance.
However, the story’s overall mood would be determined by the connotations of the language used to describe these components. Depending on the writer’s narrative tone, the piece could have a mysterious and sinister atmosphere, or an atmosphere rife with magic and romantic possibility. A
dd to the period and place, the more specific categorical factors such as weather and the time of day, and we see that a single setting can potentially convey several, very different atmospheres. We want to calibrate them all precisely to fit our intended atmosphere for the setting.
2. Harmony & Conflict Between Character & Place
Once the atmosphere is established, we want to make sure the setting counterpoints the character. One way to do that is by creating disharmony between character and setting. While we often understand how to create conflict at the inter-personal, and inner-personal levels, we often forget extra-personal conflict– conflict between character and setting.
Let’s take our example setting from earlier: our story takes place at an isolated, rundown Victorian mansion located in the English countryside. It’s midnight and there’s a thunderstorm raging. Now, what if we added to that picture an attractive young woman. She pulls up to the mansion in an expensive car and gets out wearing the latest Parisian fashion despite the weather. Even without knowing her reason for being there, the disharmony between character and setting creates an implicit conflict. Say that we learn from her thoughts that she loves Gothic architecture because it’s featured in her favourite books.
Even if she can’t see the disharmony between her naive perception and grim reality, we readers do. And we can already speculate about where things are headed and how they might turn out. All this from only a brief description of the setting and some cursory characterisation of our protagonist.
3. Symbolic Place
While symbolic place can lend dimensionality to a story, it is easily botched. The key to creating a symbolic place is to imbue the location with symbolism subtlety and unobtrusively.
- Bad: An example of story that uses ham-fisted symbolic place would be James Cameron’s Avatar. The planet Pandora is named after Pandora’s Box, which when opened, brought, sickness, pain, and death into the world. Likewise, when humans discovered the planet Pandora, they became harbingers of sickness, pain, and death for the natives. The problem with such obvious symbolism is it draws so much attention to itself that we are pulled out of the story to contemplate its inclusion.
- Good: The film In Bruges is a good example of how to use symbolic place subtly. Its real-world setting, Bruges, becomes associated with purgatory via subtle allusions throughout the film. In fact, though the film seems to be a work of pure realism at first, after multiple viewings it’s allegorical potential comes into focus. We realise Bruges symbolizes the protagonist’s internal moral struggle. It could even be literally occurring in purgatory itself.
Often beginning writers neglect the dramatic potential of their setting. They choose a place, time, and mood they find compelling or familiar, whether or those elements are significant to the character and her journey.
But what we want is a setting that heightens conflict, and creates emotional, symbolic, or thematic resonance. By understanding all the techniques for creating and conveying fictional setting at our disposal, we make sure the setting does multiple things at once.
If where and when you live is what shapes you every moment of your life, it also informs every major decision you make. So, while fictional setting may be the story’s background, it is a foreground concern.
If you’re looking for help with setting, buy our Setting Up The Setting Workbook.
Source for image
by Oliver Fox
Oliver earned his BFA from the University of Memphis (2015). After graduation, he worked as an editorial assistant for The Pinch (’16). Currently, he works as a manuscript analyst and is an MFA candidate at the University of New Orleans. He is the author of The Fantasy Workbook.
More Posts From Oliver
- Writers Talk 1: Neil Gaiman
- Hard Or Soft Worldbuilding: Which Is Right For You?
- 7 Tips To Write Like Neil Gaiman
- Janet Burroway’s 4 Aspects Of Narrative Time
- Horror Masters: 3 Spooky Tips To Write Like Lovecraft, Poe, & King
- Billy Collins’s 6 Pleasures Of Poetry
- The 5 Pillars Of Thrillers
- The 4 Pillars Of Romance
- The Super Simple Story Structure & How to Use It
- The Pros And Cons Of Plotting & Pantsing
Top Tip: Find out more about our online courses and workbooks in our shop.