How Much Magic Do You Need In A Fantasy Novel?

How Much Magic Do You Need In A Fantasy Novel?

In this post we will answer the question, ‘How much magic do you need in a fantasy novel?’

This is another post in a series on How Much questions. Previously we looked at how much blood you need in a crime novel, how much sex you need in a sex scene, how much it costs to write a book, how much detail you need in a novel, and how much profanity you need in a novel. In today’s post, we look at how much magic you need in a fantasy novel.

How Much Magic Do You Need In A Fantasy Novel?

I love fantasy and it is a very big genre. As with all genres, readers have certain expectations. With fantasy it seems that the readers are a little more invested than in other genres so the writer really has their work cut out for them.

Fantasy novels typically take place in the past and have magical elements, but note I said typically. How much is included depends on your story and the sub-genres within fantasy.

We mainly divide it into two broad categories namely, high fantasy and low fantasy. Meaning more magic or less magic, but I use the term magic loosely.

Read: 7 Ways To Create A Spectacular Magic System For Your Novel

Consider the following:   

🪄🚫 No Magic 

This is not very common but possible. Think about the book/movie The Waterhorse. It is about a friendship with a mythical creature, but there is no wand waving. It is still considered fantasy, because of the mythical creature. 

🪄🌍 Not A Lot Of Magic

Low fantasy: This is typically a story still set in reality, but with magical or fantastical elements. This can be a story set on earth and subject to the ‘rules’ of earth, but with the presence of ‘not of the earth’ elements. Low fantasy novels may have elements of telepathy, for example, but the characters still have to go to high school and worry about acne. The magic intrudes into the ‘real’ world. These books may have secondary settings and the characters move between this world and the new world.

🪄🦄🧚🏿🐲🧜🏾️ Lots Of Magic

High fantasy: Most fantasy novels fall into this category. These books take place in alternate or otherworldly settings, as in not on earth, but not usually in space (that’s sci-fi). You will have lots of magic and different creatures and beings. Worldbuilding is of the utmost importance. Think of trolls and fairies and dragons.

Read: 7 Ways To Create A Spectacular Magic System For Your Novel

🚫 Not Magic Realism

Although it is easy to think that magic realism is a part of the fantasy genre, it actually falls into a category of its own. How do you know? It’s not fantasy; and the whimsical, magic or non-realistic events or characters simply form part of the story.  The story, despite the magic, is still very firmly set in reality. The magical elements are not the primary focus, they are part of the conflict. Think about Like Water for Chocolate by Laura Esquivel or The Strange and Beautiful Sorrows of Ava Lavender by Leslye Walton.

Read: The 4 Pillars Of Magic Realism

The Last Word

There is plenty of overlap within the genre and it is up to you to decide how much magic you need to add or use.

Top Tip: Learn how to write fantasy. Buy The Fantasy Workbook

Mia Botha by Mia Botha

If you enjoyed this post, you will love:

  1. How Much Detail Do You Need In A Novel?
  2. How Much Profanity Do You Need In Your Novel?
  3. How Much Sex Do You Need In A Sex Scene?
  4. How Much Blood Do You Need In A Crime Novel?
  5. A Quick-Start Guide For Creating Characters
  6. How To Use Viewpoint As A Source Of Conflict
  7. How To Use Genre As A Source Of Conflict
  8. How To Use Sub-Plots As A Source Of Conflict
  9. How To Use Conversation As A Source Of Conflict In Fiction

Top Tip: Find out more about our workbooks and online courses in our shop.

Posted on: 9th March 2022
(1,989 views)