Discover how to use a red herring in your story to keep readers guessing, build suspense, and add an unexpected twist to your plot.
What Is A Red Herring?
Is there something fishy going on here?
A red herring is another popular storytelling device, often found in the crime genre. We see it used in mystery or detective books and films, especially when suspects enter the equation.
A red herring is a plot thread or clue introduced to divert readers’ attention from the main story events, mislead them or the characters, and lead them to draw false conclusions, usually down a literary blind alley or dead end.
They are great for plot twists.
Examples Of A Red Herring
- In Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code, Bishop Aringarosa is a classic red herring. For most of the novel, we suspect him of being the evil mastermind behind the conspiracy. It is a false conclusion on our part. In fact, he is innocent, but this plotline shrewdly distracts readers from the true antagonist of the novel.
- In the film Saw, two men wake up chained to pipes in a locked room. Between them lies what appears to be a dead body. They believe they are trapped with a victim, but the shocking ending reveals that the ‘dead’ man is alive and is the killer who forces them to play a deadly game.
- In J. K. Rowling‘s Harry Potter And The Prisoner Of Azkaban, Sirius Black appears to be the criminal who betrayed Harry’s parents to Voldemort and murdered their friend, Peter Pettigrew. However, we discover that Peter was the real traitor and had framed Sirius, making him a clever red herring.
- In the film The Usual Suspects, Verbal Kint appears to be a harmless criminal caught up in events beyond his control. However, the final twist reveals that he has been misleading the police about his identity and involvement all along.
How To Write A Red Herring In 5 Steps
- Create A Believable Suspect: Give readers a good reason to suspect the wrong character.
- Plant Misleading Clues: Introduce clues that point towards the false suspect.
- Build Suspicion Gradually: Let doubts grow through actions, dialogue, and discoveries.
- Connect It To The Main Plot: Make sure the red herring matters to the story, rather than feeling like a random distraction.
- Reveal The Truth Fairly: Surprise readers with the real answer, but make sure the clues make sense in hindsight.
A clever way to use a red herring is to use point 4 and closely intertwine it with the events of the main plot.
For example:
A movie producer with a drug habit ends up stabbed to death. His low-life drug dealer has no alibi and is branded the main suspect. Because the dealer can’t account for his time, he can be just the distraction you need in the story.
The dealer was with a major A-list Hollywood star at the time, but couldn’t reveal the star as his alibi.
However, in a plot inversion, the producer did die in a drug-related incident. He wanted to try experimental drugs with an aspiring actress, and she stabbed him in a psychotic moment.
The drugs are introduced as a compelling basis for the main plot, not just to make the drug dealer stand out as the main suspect.
You can use a red herring when plotting your novel, or you may spot an opportunity to introduce one in a second or third draft.
The Last Word
We looked at what a red herring is, explored examples from popular fiction and film, and showed how to use this clever device to mislead readers.
Source for image: Sasha Kim on Pexels

by Anthony Ehlers
More Posts From Anthony:
- How To Use Wants, Needs, And Fears To Create Better Characters
- How To Write A Character’s Moment Of Truth
- 12 Steps To Self-Editing A Manuscript: A Stress-Free Guide
- How To Write A Passive Lead Character
- 7 Types of Narcissists To Use In Your Next Story
- The MacGuffin And Chekhov’s Gun: 2 Literary Devices Writers Should Know
- What Is Visual Storytelling? 10 Essential Techniques Every Writer Should Know
- 7 Ways ‘What If?’ Helps Writers Create Better Stories
- 5 Secret Tricks To Strengthen Your Writing
- 5 Famous Writers On Writing A Villain
Top Tip: Sign up for our free daily writing links.