What can unfinished novels teach you about writing? Discover five lessons from revisiting abandoned manuscripts and learning from mistakes.
I have this secret. There is this folder on my computer. Actually, it is a folder hidden in a folder, hidden inside another folder. But regardless of how far I try to hide it, I know it is there. It lurks. It smells. It rots in quiet resignation in the bowels of my hard drive.
No, it is not an illegal snuff film collection.
It contains the carcasses of my unfinished novels. Characters that died mid-sentence, settings that dissolved into nothingness, stories that fizzled out, and plots that got me trapped.
So dramatic, isn’t it? Why don’t I delete it?
I keep this file of decaying words for a reason. I have learnt so much from these novels. Even though I failed them, they taught me something. I went through this folder again a while ago, looking for the reasons I never finished them.
5 Things I’ve Learnt From My Literary Autopsies
1. Word Count
The first thing I noticed was that I tended to stop at certain word counts. I stopped at around 5,000 words in two of them. The next three all died between 13,000 and 15,000 words. Another stopping point was 35,000 words, and one was complete at 55,000 words, but it was too one-dimensional.
I have noticed in my current work that these are the points where I struggle the most. Maybe it is psychological, but the proof is in the folder and the word count.
2. Too Ambitious
I now know that some of the plots were too ambitious for me. I was not skilled enough to tackle such a big story or such a complex plot. I might revise the plots later or use parts or characters I liked in another story. I might even try the story again much later.
3. Weak Characters
One novel failed simply because my hero’s goal and motivation weren’t strong enough. That is a mistake you only make once.
4. Silly Things
I noticed silly things that I have learnt to avoid. My male heroes all seemed to look alike. I guess I have a type. Now I make an effort to make them as different as possible.
5. Setting
I still have to work on setting. Because I skip those parts when I read, I tend to do the same when I write. I need to fix it.
What Do I Do?
These are the points where I get stuck. Experience has taught me to allow myself some breathing room here. When this happens, I step away and rewrite character biographies or revisit my synopsis.
Instead of giving up like I used to, I find a new route. I have noticed that my writing has changed a lot. I can’t say yet if that is good or bad, but I guess it will change again and again and again.
I used to have twelve problems to solve. Now that I’m aware of the problems, there are fewer and fewer. And let’s face it, it’s easier to keep going when you only have to fix something instead of everything.
These are only some of the things I have learnt. I notice new things every time I revisit the manuscripts.
Take a look at your older work and see what you can learn.
The Last Word
We looked at five lessons writers can learn from unfinished novels. Revisiting abandoned manuscripts can reveal weaknesses in plotting, characters, setting, and writing habits. Sometimes, the stories we don’t finish teach us the most.

by Mia Botha
More posts from Mia:
- Write About What Matters, Not Just What You Know
- 5 Ways To Weave Setting Into Short Stories
- How To Turn Your Short Story Into A Novella
- How To Use Genre As A Source Of Conflict
- 7 Things Dialogue Can Do In Your Story
- 4 Super Easy Ways To Create Characters For Short Stories
- How To Show Character Change Without Telling (With Examples)
- 7 Supporting Character Types Every Writer Should Know
- The 3 Surprises Every Story Needs
- A Quick Start Guide To Writing For Children
Top Tip: Sign up for our free daily writing links.