Discover how to write a Faustian story, and explore the dark art of deals with the devil to learn what makes these tales so powerful.
Stories about deals with the devil are as old as desire. From the Synoptic Gospels to the Mississippi Delta’s crossroads, Faustian tales have always been powerful ones.
Let’s take a walk and explore how to write the trickster into fiction.
What Is A Faustian Story?
The old German folk tale of Doctor Faustus is the classic example of a story deemed ‘Faustian’. It was dramatised by Christopher Marlowe in the late 1500s as The Tragical History Of The Life And Death Of Doctor Faustus.
A dissatisfied intellectual, Faustus summons the devil’s servant, Mephistopheles. He is promised wealth and knowledge in exchange for his soul when the deal comes to an end.
Does it sound familiar?
Similar stories are a staple of blues and rock lore. Musicians Robert Johnson and Tommy Johnson were both said to have made deals with the devil at a crossroads. Trickster figures such as Anansi and Papa Legba also feature in African folklore and Vodou mythology, where bargains often involve something given and something taken.
Literature explores the theme, too. Think of The Picture Of Dorian Gray, The Bottle Imp, and Needful Things. In That Hell-Bound Train by Robert Bloch a criminal is about to quit when he is offered a deal.
7 Elements Of A Faustian Story
1. The Desire
Desire is a strong element in Faustian stories. The protagonist has to want something, and want it more than anything.
The premise is based on the desire (or greed) that fuels their search for that specific thing. The protagonist must want something so badly that they are willing to risk everything to get it.
- In Doctor Faustus, Faustus becomes dissatisfied with ordinary knowledge and seeks unlimited power and supernatural abilities.
- In The Picture Of Dorian Gray, Dorian fears losing his youth and beauty and wishes to remain young forever.
- In The Invisible Life Of Addie LaRue, Addie desperately wants to escape an arranged marriage and live a life of her own choosing.
Blues legends say that Robert Johnson sold his soul for guitar skills. In the 1700s, similar legends surrounded the violinist Paganini.
Writing Tip: Desire, grief, or greed starts the Faustian plot. The protagonist wants or pursues something they just can’t get.
2. The Stranger
Faustian stories introduce a stranger who offers the protagonist a deal or gift. The stranger can be a trickster god, but can also be a demon, a lesser devil, or the devil in another form.
The hero can deliberately seek out or invoke the trickster in an attempt to gain the object of their desire. Meetings can also happen by chance, like the unmarked train carriage in That Hell-Bound Train or the mysterious Leland Gaunt in Needful Things.
- In Needful Things, Leland Gaunt arrives in Castle Rock and opens a shop that seems to know exactly what its customers desire.
- In The Devil’s Advocate, Kevin Taylor is offered an extraordinary career opportunity by the mysterious head of a powerful law firm.
- In That Hell-Bound Train, a mysterious train conductor offers a desperate passenger a chance to change his fate.
Writing Tip: Sometimes by chance, and sometimes deliberately sought out, the Faustian stranger offers the protagonist everything they might want.
3. The Deal
The next step is the deal, where the most desirable things are offered in return for an ultimate price: most often, the protagonist’s soul.
- In Doctor Faustus, Faustus signs a contract giving Lucifer his soul in exchange for twenty-four years of service from Mephistopheles.
- In The Bottle Imp, Keawe buys a bottle that grants wishes, but its owner must sell it for less than the price paid or face damnation.
- In Bearskin, a soldier agrees to serve the devil’s terms for seven years in exchange for a fortune.
Fair deal, right?
Writing Tip: A Faustian deal is entered into voluntarily by the protagonist, who accepts its terms. Sometimes with a signature, other times with a nod.
4. The Protagonist’s Life
Faustian protagonists must agree to sign their lives away and enter the bargain. Stories often show their lives after this event.
- In The Picture Of Dorian Gray, Dorian enjoys a life of pleasure and excess while his portrait records the physical and moral damage he escapes.
- In The Invisible Life Of Addie LaRue, Addie spends centuries travelling the world, experiencing history and meeting people who cannot remember her.
- In Bearskin, the soldier enjoys his newfound wealth but must live with the restrictions of his bargain, including wearing a bearskin and avoiding washing for seven years.
The protagonist is often allowed to reap the benefits of the deal, but only until the next step.
Writing Tip: Faustian deals play out over at least some of the plot, allowing the protagonist to get what they wanted. It is often not exactly what they wanted, or not exactly as they wanted it.
5. The Fine Print
Deals that seem ideal will always have conditions in a Faustian story. All bargains have fine print.
- In The Bottle Imp, the bottle can only be sold at a lower price than its previous purchase price, making each new sale more difficult.
- In Needful Things, customers must perform small favours for Gaunt, which gradually turn neighbours against one another.
- In The Invisible Life Of Addie LaRue, Addie discovers that nobody can remember her once she leaves their sight, making ordinary relationships impossible.
Writing Tip: Fine print is where conflict gets to shine. Faustian fine print is designed to add an element of (usually dark) surprise, and something the protagonist did not imagine. Summarise your deal’s premise in a sentence, then add ‘…but’ to stipulate yours.
6. The Bargain’s End
The Faustian deal comes to an end, and the stranger (whether demon or devil) returns to collect. Darkness, loss, mortality, and the consequences of blind greed or debauchery are common themes.
- In Doctor Faustus, the twenty-four years expire, and Mephistopheles comes to collect Faustus’s soul.
- In The Picture Of Dorian Gray, Dorian tries to destroy the portrait that holds the evidence of his corruption, but the act leads to his own death.
- In The Devil’s Advocate, Kevin Taylor discovers the true identity and intentions of his employer, and must confront the consequences of his ambition.
Faustian endings are almost always dark, rooted in tragedy or great loss.
Writing Tip: Traditional Faustian endings are often tragic when the deal expires. The protagonist may lose their soul, their freedom, or something they love. Sometimes the greatest cost is not the bargain itself, but what they must sacrifice to escape it.
7. The Alternate Ending
The stranger doesn’t always succeed. Alternate endings are also possible, where the protagonist finds a way out of the deal and walks away.
It’s a less common way to end a Faustian story, but it has been done.
- In The Bottle Imp, Keawe and Kokua find a way to sell the bottle for a fraction of its previous price, escaping its curse.
- In Gimmicks Three, the protagonist uses time travel to return to a point before the deal takes place.
- In That Hell-Bound Train, the protagonist boards the train to escape his fate, but becomes its new conductor instead. This is an alternative ending with a dark twist rather than a true escape.
Writing Tip: An unexpected ending can make your Faustian story memorable. Think carefully about how your protagonist might outwit the stranger, escape the bargain, or turn its terms against them.
The Faustian Tale: Story ExamplesÂ
- The Invisible Life Of Addie LaRue by V. E. Schwab
- The Tragical Life & Death Of Doctor Faustus by Christopher Marlowe
- That Hell-Bound Train by Robert Bloch
- Needful Things by Stephen King
- The Picture Of Dorian Gray by Oscar Wilde
- The Bottle Imp by Robert Louis Stevenson
- Bearskin by The Brothers Grimm
- Gimmick Three by Isaac Asimov
- The Devil’s Advocate by Andrew Neiderman
The Last Word
We explored the Faustian story and its seven key elements, from the protagonist’s deepest desire and the stranger’s tempting offer to the fine print and the final bargain. We also looked at how writers can use traditional tragic endings or find a clever way for their characters to escape.
Source for image: Eduardo González on Pexels
By Alex J. Coyne. Alex is a writer, proofreader, and regular card player. His features about cards, bridge, and card playing have appeared in Great Bridge Links, Gifts for Card Players, Bridge Canada Magazine, and Caribbean Compass.
If you enjoyed this, read:
- What Is Genre? A Guide To The 17 Most Popular Fiction Genres
- Here Be Dragons – 7 Tips For Writing Dragons In Fiction
- What Is Dystopian Fiction & How Do I Write It?
- The 5 Pillars Of Speculative Fiction
- The Strange World of Slipstream Fiction – What Is It?
- How To Write Alternate History: A Complete Guide For Writers
- The 4 Pillars Of Magic Realism
- What Is Steampunk? How To Write Steampunk Fiction
- How To Write A Vampire Story: History, Themes, And Tips
- Gothic Fiction: 8 Essential Elements Every Writer Should Know
Top Tip: Sign up for our free daily writing links.